Skip to content
Cover art for the episode

Cropsey

This Wednesday night at 9pm at midnight at 3am in a cemetery...
Frank tells the spooky urban legend of a crazed Staten Island serial killer and finds out there might be more to the tale than legend.

The story of Cropsey, a murderous madman with a hook for a hand, was whispered in the dark by kids at summer camp, and was even told to misbehaving children to scare them into shape. It was said he camped out in the woods of the Green Belt in Staten Island, a particularly green borough of New York City. His lair was said to be in the abandoned Willowbrook State School, a all-too-long-lived institution for children with intellectual disabilities, where horrible abuse was directed at the poor residents for decades before being shut down. Was Cropsey a previous patient who escaped and set out to enact the same tortute he received on other children? Or perhaps he was one of the workers who delighted in abusing the helpless kids? Where'd his hand go???

In this episode, our first ever in spooky season, Frank relays the urban legend before diving into the historicity of the story. Unfortunately, this tale doesn't stay a legend. While the story of Cropsey was traumatizing kids in the 70's and 80's... actual children were going missing in Staten Island.

Photographs

andre_rand_headshot.png
Figure 1: Andre Rand, born Frank Rostum Rushan, associated with the Cropsey legend.
andre_rand_trial.png
Figure 2: Andre Rand, being led out of the Staten Island Supreme Court for a kidnapping charge.

Discussed Locations

Willowbrook State School, Staten Island, NY

In This Episode

Frank Matranga

Frank Matranga

Host

Nicholas Oertel

Nicholas Oertel

Co-Host

Aaron Reers

Aaron Reers

Co-Host

What Do You Think?